JCTP Article, A Ticket to the Big Game: How Newbigin, Polanyi and Marsden Gave Me Plausibility during Perilous Doctoral Research and Post-Pandemic Teaching

Robert WoodsMember Publications: Other, News: Other Leave a Comment

Return to Journal of Christian Teaching Practice (in Communication Studies), Vol. 13, 2026

A Ticket to the Big Game: How Lesslie Newbigin, Michael Polanyi and George Marsden Gave Me Plausibility during Perilous Doctoral Research and Post-Pandemic Teaching

Michael A. Longinow, Biola University (retired)

Abstract: in their seminal works, Mark Noll and George Marsden raise questions in the late twentieth century about the failure of evangelical Christian colleges and universities to distinguish themselves as centers of intellectual rigor. Noll claims secular universities, with a fervor for research and cutting-edge thought, have long outpaced the work of Christian scholars in the creation of critically important knowledge. Marsden traces evangelical scholars’ lack of fervor through a history that involves an inevitable slide out of Christian mission into secularity and obscurity within American higher education. This essay challenges Noll and Marsden on key assumptions and conclusions by drawing on personal experience and the plausibility structures of Lesslie Newbigin and Michael Polanyi, among others, which provided the author with a biblical perspective for bridging rigorous Christian and secular thought.

 

To be a faculty member in a Christian liberal arts college or university in the early decades of the twenty-first century entails paradoxes that would delight G.K. Chesterton.[1] It is a blending of identities. It requires teaching with a grasp of (even if in disagreement with) what Mark Noll suggests has been a long-brewing anti-intellectualism within evangelical culture.[2] At the same time, it requires shrewd faith integration into one’s discipline, along with skill at crafting intellectual inquiry capable of publishable, peer-reviewed research.

George Marsden’s inquiry into the soul of the American university speaks to this mix. He contends that the history of meaning in American universities, Christian or otherwise, lies not in the quest for new knowledge. Our attention need not be diverted by the replacement of theology as “queen of the sciences” with science as a faith system devoid of any awareness of God.[3] What matters instead is a tracing of academics’ pursuit of what to do with that nagging sense of the numinous underlying all thoughtful inquiry, or that something from which morality springs, that something which is beyond reason and experience.[4] Historians of American higher education differ in their engagement with this contention, but they generally agree with Marsden’s claims.[5]

Marsden’s point, along with Noll’s, bears heavily on the future of the Academy, and academics, in colleges and universities that claim a Christian mission. Most of these schools are particularly tuition dependent.[6] Stability in enrollment drives the viability of academic programs, curricula, even institutions’ very existence. The paradox is that for a school to be measurably Christian, it must defend its biblical mission; yet to pursue viability can require compromises of institutional conscience aimed at increasing or preserving enrollment.[7]

A driving factor in this equation is students. They are a paradox as well. University leaders are eyeing their concerns.[8] Students believe in God, but they don’t; many bring questions about whether biblical principles can align with, let alone be woven into, the fabric of their academic discipline, or their daily lives.[9] Students’ peripheral vision is on business or ministry start-ups, social media influencers and entrepreneurs[10]

 My Plausibility, the Life of the Mind, and Christian Liberal Arts Education

This essay will use the theory of plausibility structures as a tool to question and refute Mark Noll’s claim, in The Scandal of the Evangelical Mind, that teaching-focused Christian liberal arts colleges and universities lack the capacity to form the kinds of wide-ranging knowledge that have value when juxtaposed with the scholarly output of land-grant and private research universities. It will also use plausibility structures as handholds to underscore the claim made by Arthur Holmes that the very act of integrated teaching, that is, a systematic blending of biblical truth with a given academic discipline, is, itself, an act of scholarly work.[11] Noll’s definition of scandal, I will suggest, is far too sweeping a term. Noll’s denigrating of scholarship and intellectual pursuits among evangelicals could itself be called scandal. My aim in this chapter will be to support the complicated, often misunderstood quest of making the synthesis of career-focused pedagogy within a liberal arts education meaningful to students in the twenty-first century. My argument will focus on the work of Christian academics, but it has implications for those with evangelical beliefs outside academia.[12]

I am uniquely equipped to confront these paradoxes as an academic because I entered the Academy without what Lesslie Newbgin (and Peter Berger) would call a necessary plausibility structure for scholarly success.[13] Having been raised in Chicago, having completed a Master of Science in news journalism at the University of Illinois, my move from the newsroom to the classroom was driven not merely by Midwestern pragmatism, but by a sense of calling, one I considered biblical, to uncover hidden truth and bring societal remedies for injustice. My career journey after graduate school, which was in part a response to a deep reading of All the President’s Men, entailed two years of city news reporting near Chicago.[14] Then I moved to Georgia where I encountered geographic marginalization (Northern-born reporter seeking answers in the Deep South), which led me to get training in document-driven investigation. That new skill helped me examine unethical bank lending practices, systemic racism in business, and local government corruption through political cronyism. The year before signing my first faculty contract to teach English and journalism, I took my press pass into a convention complex in Atlanta, interviewing and photographing presidential candidates at the Democratic National Convention. Before that, I met and interviewed Mujahadeen fighters in a Georgia hospital recovering from battle wounds in Afghanistan; and I studied the protest strategies of ACT UP, an activist LGBTQ movement that helped to shake the national discourse on gender.[15]

But I found that my commitment to investigation leading to change through journalism had no clear equivalent in Christian undergraduate academia. My very choice to enter this world was challenged by a hiring committee at Asbury University that questioned the legitimacy of a media professional’s contributions in a liberal arts setting. They doubted the value of my skills-driven Master of Science degree and whether it gave me the scholarly tools necessary to enhance the life of the mind they believed true academia required. Despite some committee misgivings, I was hired on tenure track and given seven years to complete a doctorate. Few guided my steps into those doctoral studies. What could a news reporter possibly bring to the intellectual table?

Finding the Handholds: Newbigin, Polanyi and The Sympathizers

The answer lay waiting in archived documents in scholarly libraries. Much in the way I had approached public records in my investigative journalism, I looked deeply into these documents, i.e., collected papers, correspondence, publications, and found a mostly-ignored thread of Christian faith commitment and revivalist spirituality that, by means of media voices, linked aspirations of the earliest colonial colleges and universities with the development of modernist and post-modernist thought in 20th century universities. Marshall McLuhan’s contention that the medium—in this case higher education—was the message became my vehicle forward[16]

A parallel help were the plausibility structures embraced by Lesslie Newbigin. A sympathetic scholar at Asbury Theological Seminary introduced me to Newbigin’s work; That writing, in turn, introduced me to the thinking of Michael Polanyi and Peter Berger.[17] I had read a bit of Berger, specifically his Sacred Canopy in college but it had little resonance for me in the sheltered Christian liberal arts setting where I was rarely challenged in my theories of knowledge.[18] I hit those challenges in my doctoral coursework. Faculty there embraced and invited me into the thinking of Michel Foucault, Richard Rorty, Friederich Nietzsche, Paolo Friere, and Kenneth Bruffee, among many others.[19]

It was Newbigin’s (and Berger’s) theories of plausibility that gave me a kind of deflective shield against post-modern critics: religious beliefs, I found, are maintained by social networks and rituals whose value is undeniable in existential ways.

Plausibility structures, as described by Newbigin, are concepts borrowed from Polanyi, whose sense of personal knowledge pushes back against the systematic skepticism inherent in pluralistic thinking. That pushback is grounded in an awareness of God’s place in the universe and the sense that truth is out there to be found.[20] I needed this reassurance, for in my doctoral studies I navigated an intellectual world where scholars viewed history and truth as fungible, subject to the intimations of reader response theory and socially constructed meaning.

Another help came from Roman Catholic scholar Walter Ong’s seminal research in orality and literacy, which gave me a theoretical handhold on the very meaning of oral cultures inherent in reporting practices of journalism for print, broadcast and digital news in western cultures.[21]

Berger was a sociologist, but his work had implications for communication within religion (I could situate journalism within these) as systems informed by God’s design in human encounter.[22] From Martin Buber’s 1937 classic I and Thou, I found ways to situate even as mundane a journalistic procedure as the news interview in significant theory of discursive meaning. Buber, bringing his Jewish cultural thought to my work, helped me explain how the pursuit and conducting of journalistic interviews could exhibit biblical wisdom, empathy and compassion.[23]

Newbigin, the Scandal, and my Doubt of the Doubters

To find a plausibility in my stance as a Christian researcher amid doubting faculty in my doctoral classes was a relief at many levels. Doubting my doubters there built a kind of intellectual muscle that gave me confidence. From Newbigin I learned that postmodern assertions about the incapacity of religious faith to survive under intellectual scrutiny were a kind of dogma, a faith perspective;[24] my dissertation chair and committee accepted my scholarly propositions better when I was able to converse with their assertions about truth. Fearlessness in the face of their questions and criticisms brought respect for the intellectual moment. My doctoral committee announced my dissertation approval with what felt like a grudging respect.

Back on my own campus, I confronted doubters of another kind. I was able to bring a plausibility to my stance of practical journalist, with one foot firmly in the camp of experiential news-industry preparation for students, and scholar of media history and communication, with the other foot also firmly in the camp of theorists probing the meaning of orality, literacy, and media identities in a digitizing world. Within weeks of my dissertation defense, I was called before the same faculty review committee that, with misgivings, had hired me, and this time for tenure review. I was granted tenure; the committee chair wrote that my portfolio was overwhelming in its defense of criteria.

Through all these experiences, I brought plausibility to the notion that Noll and Marsden had each, in their own way, erred in their criticisms of, and generalizations about Christian higher education. As I had done earlier with Newbigin’s guidance, I doubted their doubts. Noll was wrong in his doubts about Holiness scholars. True, there was in my experience some angst, discussion and frustration about the role of research and intellectual inquiry among Holiness scholars.[25] I find in both Noll and Marsden evidence of a hubris of Calvinist thought that disdains any scholarly approach other than theirs. Having lived and researched alongside many of Holiness scholars, I found enormous intellectual strength in their inquiry. Yes, they held the power of the Holy Spirit in high regard, but this did not make them a people prone to “letting go and letting God,” as Noll put it. Marsden was accurate in tracing the slow erosion of biblical mission in many Christian colleges and universities in the United States over time. He does have some suggestions for better scholarship by Christians in the twenty-first century.[26] But he glosses over those whose convictions for biblical integration stood firm.

Where Noll claimed that no significant research was emerging from the relatively tiny Christian colleges and universities across the U.S., I consistently found significant new inquiry getting published by my colleagues at Asbury and at other smaller schools in the Council for Christian Colleges and Universities. Yes, their research got attention at evangelical scholars’ gatherings, journals and books, which was necessary and significant dialogue, but it was also published in notable university presses in the United States and in Europe. And it emerged as part of significant intellectual conversations with scholars who, even if not part of a Christian community (they were often Jewish, Muslim, Hindu), respected their questions and suggestions about morality, ethics and the ways humans should live beside each other.

Where Marsden claimed that secular, pluralistic trends bring an inevitable destruction of biblical mission in serious higher education, his tracking of this concept was limited to the thinking and policymaking of leaders in offices and board rooms of administration buildings. What he missed was the very potent undercurrents of the extra-curriculum within all higher education. Social historian Helen Horowitz and others note that there are worlds that students create within any college or university that have lasting impact on their minds and lives. In some respects, this is more significant for careers and human development than university policies or students’ majors, and which can even shape policy and curriculum at these schools over time. This trend is no less true at Christian liberal arts colleges and universities; the internationally acclaimed “outpouring” at Asbury University in 2023 is one recent manifestation of this.[27]

What neither Noll nor Marsden take into account is the significant, very intellectual work of Holy Spirit-led integration of biblical principles into innovative pedagogy and curriculum. Such integration is hard work; not all faculty invest in it, but many scholars do.[28] It is a commitment many faculty pursue across the hundreds of Christian colleges and universities nationally. Having served on search committees for new faculty, and having been part of new faculty orientation workshops, I have been consistently impressed with the newly minted Ph.Ds and even faculty from research universities who come to evangelical Christian universities excited about weaving biblical insight into the humanities, business, the Arts, or sciences. Faculty from Biola’s Rosemead School of Psychology produce nationally recognized research on such topics as anxiety, attachment theory, suffering, discrimination, and cultural humility. The Crowell School of Business at Biola in the last two years, has built a center for biblical understanding and practices of artificial intelligence, a crucial topic for all in higher education. Biola’s School of Fine Arts and Communication has launched a Winsome Conviction Project aimed at the study and practice of biblically grounded civil discourse in our divided nation. At Wheaton College, where Noll taught for many years, psychologist Mark Yarhouse, formerly at Regent University, has taken leadership of the Sexual and Gender Identity Institute, fielding research that is cutting-edge for not just Christian educators but any college or university seeking to understand student thinking and formation in understanding of the self.[29]

Scholars such as Noll and Marsden who dissect and speak critically of American higher education, and Christians within it, will be with us for the foreseeable future. Yet the calling and work of biblical integration into undergraduate education remains. I’ve chosen it. And I’ve found that parents of students in evangelical homes (and in homes with little to no faith commitment) remain fascinated by, even hungry for such integration, and they will pay for it. And as I suit up to join the faculty of my university for commencement ceremonies each Spring, I’m reminded again that I’m not alone.

Notes

[1] G. K. Chesterton, Orthodoxy (San Francisco: Ignatius Press: 1908/1995), 90–91.

[2] Mark A. Noll, The Scandal of the Evangelical Mind (Eerdmans, 1994). 3–4.

[3] Avihu Zakai, “The Rise of Modern Science and the Decline of Theology as the ‘Queen of the Sciences’ in the Early Modern Era,” Reformation & Renaissance Review 9 no. 2 (2015): 125–152; Mike Higton, A Theology of Higher Education (Oxford University Press, 2012), 1–2; Mary K. Tillman, “The Tension between Intellectual and Moral Education in the Thought of John Henry Newman,” Thought: Fordham University Quarterly 60 no. 3 (1985): 322–334.

[4] Jesse J. Thomas, “From Joy to Joy: C. S. Lewis and The Numinous,” Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies 12, nos.1–2 (2000): 109–124; George Marsden, The Soul of the American University: From Protestant Establishment to Established Nonbelief (Oxford University Press, 1994), 369–375; Marsden, “Introduction,” The Secularization of the Academy, ed. George Marsden and Bradley Longfield (Oxford University Press, 1992), 3–7.

 

[5] Frederick Rudolph, The American College and University: A History (University of Georgia Press, 1990), 481–482; Laurence Veysey, The Emergence of the American University (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1965), 133–134.

[6] Denise Daniels, Caleb Henry and Bradley J. Murg, “The Future of Christian Higher Education: A Political Economy Analysis,” Journal of Markets & Morality 22 no. 2 (2022); Michael T. Falder (2021), Advancement’s Role in Enhancing Financial Viability at Christian Colleges (PhD diss, Regent University, 2021).

[7] Meg L. DuMez, “Mission, Money and Motivation: A Case Study of Traditional and Adult Undergraduate Programs at a Christian College” (PhD diss, Azusa Pacific University, 2018);

Richard H. Johnson, “A Case Study of One Small Christian College overcoming Decline and Implementing an Institutional Turnaround” (PhD diss., Abilene Christian University, 2021).

[8] Colleen Flaherty, “Presidents Weigh in on the Public Confidence Crisis,” Inside Higher Ed (March 6, 2025); Hilary A. Edwards, “Navigating the Unprecedented: A Study on How Senior Administrators in Higher Education Learned and Made Decisions during the COVID-19 Pandemic” (PhD diss. University of Maryland, 2024); Xinqiao Liu and Jingxuan Wang, “Depression, Anxiety, and Student Satisfaction with University Life Among College Students: A Cross-Lagged Study,” Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 11 no. 1172 (2024): 1–11.

[9]  Barna, “Doubt & Faith: Top Reasons People Question Christianity” (March 1, 2023), https://www.barna.com/research/doubt-faith/; Patricia Wittberg, “Generational Change in Religion and Religious Practice: A Review Essay,” Review of Religious Research 63, no. 3 (2021): 461–482.

[10]  Phil Davignon, “Factors Influencing College Choice and Satisfaction mong Students at Christian Colleges and Universities,” Religion & Education 43, no. 1 (2015): 77–94; Todd C. Ream and Perry L. Glanzner, The Idea of a Christian College: A Re-examination for Today’s University (Cascade Books, 2013).

[11] Arthur F. Holmes, “What About Student Integration?” Journal of Research on Christian Education 3 no.1 (2009): 3–5; Arthur F. Holmes, “The Methodology of Christian Philosophy,” The Journal of Religion 42, no. 3 (1962): 215–216; Jessica Daniels, “Christian Education as Sacred Liminal Space,” Christian Scholars Review 51, no. 2 (2022): 189–200.

[12] Beverly Johson-Miller and Robert W. Pazmino, “Christian Education Foundations: Retrospects and Prospects,” Christian Education Journal: Research on Education Ministry 17 no. 3 (2020): 1–17; Morne Diedricks, “Calvin’s Use of the Scholastic Method from his Vision of the Church as Mother and School,” The Expository Times 136 no. 7 (2025): 296–308; Gary D. Hyrne, “Cultivating Advanced Education for Christian Faculty in Higher Education Institutions: A Phenomenological Study” (PhD diss, Liberty University, 2025).

[13]  Lesslie Newbigin, The Gospel in a Pluralist Society (Eerdmans, 1989); Robin Gill, “Berger’s Plausibility Structures: A Response to Professor Cairns,” Scottish Journal of Theology 27, no. 2 (1974): 198–207.

[14] Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, All the President’s Men (Simon & Schuster, 1974); Pakula, Alan J., director, All the President’s Men [Film], Warner Brothers, 1976.

[15] Alexandra Juhasz, “Forgetting ACT UP,” Quarterly Journal of Speech 98, no.1 (2012): 69–74.; Craig Gingrich-Philbrook, “ACT UP as a Structure of Feeling.” Quarterly Journal of Speech 98, no. 1 (2012) 81–88.

[16] Jim Euchner, “The Medium is the Message,” Research-Technology Management 59, no. 5 (2016): 9–11; Kenneth E. Boulding, “The Medium and the Message,” The Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science 31, no. 2 (1965): 268–273; Marshall McLuhan, Understanding Media: The Extensions of Man (McGraw-Hill, 1964), 4–8.

[17] Richard Gelwick, The way of discovery: An Introduction to the thought of Michael Polanyi. (Wipf & Stock, 1977); Michael M. Polanyi, The Tacit Dimension (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1966), xiii–xiv.

[18] Peter Berger, The Sacred Canopy: Elements of a Sociological Theory of Religion (Doubleday, 1967).

[19] Michel Foucault, Madness and Civilization (Vintage Books, 1998); Richard Rorty,

Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature (Princeton University Press, 1981); Friedrich Nietzsche,  Beyond Good and Evil: Prelude to a Philosophy of the Future, trans. Walter Kaufmann (Vintage Books, 1886/1966); Paolo Friere, Pedagogy of the Oppressed, trans. M.B. Ramos (Continuum, 1970/1993); Kenneth A. Bruffee, “Social Construction, Language, and the Authority of Knowledge: A Bibliographical Essay,” College English 48, no. 8 (1986): 773–790.

[20] Michael M. Polanyi, Meaning (University of Chicago Press, 1975).

[21] Walter J. Ong, “Communications Media and the State of Theology.” CrossCurrents 19, no. 4 (1969): 462–480; Walter J. Ong, Orality and Literacy: The Technologizing of the Word (London: Methuen, 1982).; Rishi Raj Bahl, Outsourcing our Memory 2.0: Using Walter Ong’s Orality/Literacy Studies to Recognize Technologies Effects on Memory (Phd diss, Duquesne University, 2017).

[22] Philip Gorski and Jeffrey Guhin, “The Ongoing Plausibility of Peter Berger: Sociological Thoughts on the Sacred Canopy at Fifty,” Journal of the American Academy of Religion 85, no. 4 (2017): 1118, 1131.

[23] Martin Buber, I and Thou, trans. Walter Gregor Smith (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1984; orig. pub. 1937); Oren O. Soffer, “The Competing Ideals of Objectivity and Dialogue in American journalism,” Journalism 10, no. 4 (2009); Ronald C. Arnett, Communication and Community: Implications of Martin Buber’s Dialogue (Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press, 1986).

[24] Lesslie Newbigin, The Gospel in a Pluralist Society (Eerdmans, 1989), 8–9.

[25] Kenneth Collins, “Why the Holiness Movement is Dead,” Asbury Theological Journal 54, no. 2 (1999): 1–10; Andrew C. Thompson, “From Societies to Society: The Shift from Holiness to Justice in the Wesleyan Tradition,” Methodist Review 3 (2011); Joy L. Arroyo,” John Wesley’s Empowered Regimen: Cultivating Health and Sanctification, Wesley and Methodist Studies 13, no. 2 (2021): 154–174.

[26] George Marsden, The Outrageous Idea of Christian Scholarship (Oxford University Press, 2024), 49–66.

[27] Helen Lefkowitz, Campus Life: Undergraduate Cultures from the End of the Eighteenth Century to the Present (University of Chicago Press, 1988); Jeffrey M. Stuber, “Class, Culture and Participation in the Collegiate Extra-curriculum,” Sociological Forum 24, no. 4 (2009): 877–900; Julian Woodward, “The Extra-Curriculum as an Educational Institution,” Bulletin of the American Association of University Professors (1915–1955) 31 no. 3 (1945): 383–391; Michael S. Hevel and Heidi A. Jaeckle, “Trends in the Historiography of American College Student Life: Populations, Organizations and Behavior,” in Rethinking Campus Life: Historical Studies in Education ed. Christiane A. Ogren and Marc A. VanOverbeke (Cham, Switzerland: Palgrave Macmillan); Jonathan A. Powers, “Unmute Yourself: Attentive to God’s Presence: Reflections on the Asbury Outpouring,” Liturgy 38 no. 4 (2023), 11–14; Alexa Groen, “Effect of Extra-Curricular Activities on Students’ Spiritual Growth” (Masters thesis, Dordt College, 2017).

[28] Gregory D. Richardson, “Faith and Learning in Higher Education: Merging the Bible with Discipline Specific Content,” Journal of Research on Christian Education 28 no. 1 (2019): 51–70; Daisy Savarirajan and Su Fong, “Bridging Bible and Biology: The Impact of Faith Integration on the Spiritual Growth of Students in Christian Higher Education,” Journal of Instructional Research 8 no. 1 (2019): 5–16; Ken Bradley, “The Faith/Learning Integration Movement in Christian Higher Education: Slogan or Substance?” Journal of Research on Christian Education 3 no. 1 (1994): 13–33; Elizabeth Sinclair Powell, Theresa Tisdale, Michelle Willingham, Joy Bustrum and Claire Allan, “Faith Development in Graduating Christian College Seniors,” Christian Higher Education 11 no. 3, (2012): 177–191.

[29] Mark Yarhouse, “Sexual Identity Development: The Influence of Valuative Frameworks on Identity Synthesis,” Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, Practice, Training 38 no. 3 (2001): 331–341; Mark A. Yarhouse, Stephen P. Stratton and Heather L. Brooke, “Listening to Sexual Minorities on Christian College Campuses, Journal of Psychology and Theology 37 no. 2 (2009): 96–113; Stanton L. Jones and Mark A. Yarhouse, “A Longitudinal Study of Attempted Religiously Mediated Sexual Orientation Change, Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy 37 no. 5 (2011): 404–427.

Leave a Reply